Jun 28, 2019 11:04
4 yrs ago
1 viewer *
Dutch term

godsdienst en religie

Dutch to English Social Sciences Religion
In a book on world religions, the author want to distinguish between these two words, which according to him are often used interchangeably. Normally I would have translated 'godsdienst' as religion, but that doesn't work for this. I toyed with using 'worship', 'faith' or 'belief', but wonder if anyone can think of any other options. Thanks!

Here are some examples sentences:

- "vaak worden de woorden godsdienst en religie door elkaar gebruikt, maar ten onrechte"
- "Religie is echt niet hetzelfde als godsdienst"

Discussion

telraam Jun 28, 2019:
Religion (religie) is the umbrella term that covers all the various denominations (godsdiensten). The latter would be used for Catholic, Protestant, Buddhism, etc.
philgoddard Jun 28, 2019:
Agree with Textpertise This is a distinction in Dutch, but I'm not sure it applies in English. Depending on what comes next, you may have to leave out these passages.
If you look up "godsdienst" in a dictionary, it says "religion".
Here's what Wikipedia says about "religie":

Vaak wordt ook de term geloof gebruikt. In monotheïstische religies wordt ook het specifiekere begrip godsdienst gebruikt (niet alleen geloven in God, maar Hem ook dienen).
Textpertise Jun 28, 2019:
What comes next? In order to make any meaningful suggestion, you need to tell us why your author thinks they are different from each other and how he is distinguishing between the two words. Reading on is the first step I would need to do in order to know what to think.

Proposed translations

1 day 33 mins
Selected

beliefs and religion

beliefs is better than faith in this case I would say. More geared toward the divine.
Something went wrong...
2 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thank you! I ended up using 'belief system' vs. 'religion', but this gave me the idea ;)"
47 mins

Religion and faith

I have also considered "belief systems", but this goes beyond religion and can include philosophy, political and other beliefs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belief#Belief_systems
Something went wrong...

Reference comments

2 hrs
Reference:

Godsdienst of religie

Politici zoals Balkenende zouden onderscheid moeten maken tussen religie en godsdienst.

Religie: een diepe ervaring van iets groters dan de mens. Elke mens is religieus. Religie verbindt mensen.

Godsdienst: mensen willen over die ervaring praten; geven er namen aan -Jahweh, God, Allah- bedenken er verhalen over, scheppen rituelen. Godsdiensten willen religie bewaren, beleven en doorgeven aan het nageslacht. Godsdiensten zijn als het ware mantels om religie heengeslagen. Mantels gemaakt door mensen uit een bepaalde tijd, cultuur. Mantels die voortdurend ruimer, modieuzer gemaakt moeten worden, soms hersteld.

Godsdiensten kunnen dynamisch zijn als ze mensen met elkaar verbinden; mensen helpen `mens` te worden. Godsdiensten zijn dynamiet als een godsdienst zich de enig ware gaat noemen. Zo worden andere godsdiensten tot tweederangs geloven verklaard en worden mensen van elkaar vervreemd.

https://www.trouw.nl/nieuws/godsdienst-of-religie~b838a192/

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2 hrs (2019-06-28 13:30:39 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

You may need a workaround.
For example:

Religie is echt niet hetzelfde als godsdienst.

A clear distinction should be made between religion and religious systems.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 7 hrs (2019-06-28 18:30:39 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

The question is: Is there not truth in religions, in theories, in ideals, in beliefs?

Let us examine. What do we mean by religion? Surely, not organized religion, not Hinduism, Buddhism, or Christianity—which are all organized beliefs with their propaganda, conversion, proselytism, compulsion, and so on. Is there any truth in organized religion? It may engulf, enmesh truth, but the organized religion itself is not true. Therefore, organized religion is false, it separates man from man. You are a Muslim, I am a Hindu, another is a Christian or a Buddhist—and we are wrangling, butchering each other. Is there any truth in that? We are not discussing religion as the pursuit of truth, but we are considering if there is any truth in organized religion. We are so conditioned by organized religion to think there is truth in it that we have come to believe that by calling oneself a Hindu, one is somebody, or one will find God. How absurd, sir; to find God, to find reality, there must be virtue. Virtue is freedom, and only through freedom can truth be discovered—not when you are caught in the hands of organized religion, with its beliefs. And is there any truth in theories, in ideals, in beliefs? Why do you have beliefs? Obviously, because beliefs give you security, comfort, safety, a guide. In yourself you are frightened, you want to be protected, you want to lean on somebody, and therefore you create the ideal, which prevents you from understanding that which is. Therefore, an ideal becomes a hindrance to action.

https://hinduism.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1360/shoul...
Note from asker:
Thank you for the helpful references!
Peer comments on this reference comment:

agree Kitty Brussaard : Helpful references and the proposed workaround is definitely one worth considering.
22 hrs
Thank you, Kitty. Yes, seems to me a good/useful 'working hypothesis'
agree Peter Simon
1 day 19 hrs
Thank you, Peter.
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search