Glossary entry

Russian term or phrase:

реабилитирующие основания

English translation:

exculpatory grounds

Added to glossary by Frank Szmulowicz, Ph. D.
Dec 21, 2021 16:23
2 yrs ago
19 viewers *
Russian term

реабилитирующие основания

Russian to English Law/Patents Law (general) criminal law
уголовное дело подлежит прекращению по реабилитирующим основаниям
Change log

Jan 7, 2022 02:00: Frank Szmulowicz, Ph. D. Created KOG entry

Discussion

Denis Fesik Dec 22, 2021:
'Реабилитирующие' as a simplification The list of grounds referred to in Article 133 of the Russian Code of Civil Procedure is designated as grounds for creation of a right to rehabilitation, which makes all the sense to me while the term 'реабилитирующие основания' (which never occurs in that article) sounds a bit odd because the grounds themselves don't rehabilitate a criminal (hence the third suggestion – grounds for rehabilitation, which can also be used here albeit with a change in wording), so we're dealing with simplified language; 'rehabilitative grounds' sound better than 'реабилитирующие основания' because this expression doesn't necessarily imply what the grounds do, but there's still something about this term that sounds wrong to me; if it is used in this sense, I'm prepared to buy in on it
Oleg Lozinskiy Dec 21, 2021:
В отношении перевода "юридически значимых" текстов я руководствуюсь кодексами тех стран, чьи тексты в данный момент переводятся. В данном случае, частью 2 статьи 133 УПК РФ (в которой приведен исчерпывающий перечень "реабилитирующих оснований" и которую легко найти в сети как на русском, так и на английском языке).

Словоблок "на реабилитирующих основаниях" внедрился в русский язык из англоязычной юриспруденции (ст.133 открывает 'Chapter 18. Rehabilitation'), а приведенный мной в моем ответе пример взят из постановления UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS.
Frank Szmulowicz, Ph. D. Dec 21, 2021:
I understand rehabilitation to be a program that re-educates a criminal and returns him/her to society as a productive, law-abiding member.
Oleg Lozinskiy Dec 21, 2021:
on exonerative / exculpatory grounds -> на оправдательных основаниях

on rehabilititative grounds -> на реабилитирующих основаниях

Ст. 133 УПК РФ:

2. Право на реабилитацию, в том числе право на возмещение вреда, связанного с уголовным преследованием, имеют: 1) подсудимый, в отношении которого вынесен оправдательный приговор; 2) подсудимый, уголовное преследование в отношении которого прекращено в связи с отказом государственного обвинителя от обвинения; 3) подозреваемый или обвиняемый, уголовное преследование в отношении которого прекращено по основаниям, предусмотренным пунктами 1, 2, 5 и 6 части первой статьи 24 и пунктами 1 и 4-6 части первой статьи 27 настоящего Кодекса; 4) осужденный - в случаях полной или частичной отмены вступившего в законную силу обвинительного приговора суда и прекращения уголовного дела по основаниям, предусмотренным пунктами 1 и 2 части первой статьи 27 настоящего Кодекса; 5) лицо, к которому были применены принудительные меры медицинского характера, - в случае отмены незаконного или необоснованного постановления суда о применении данной меры.
https://upkod.ru/chast-1/razdel-6/glava-18/st-133-upk-rf
Frank Szmulowicz, Ph. D. Dec 21, 2021:
To exonerate is to clear or absolve from blame or a criminal charge
https://www.thefreedictionary.com/exonerate
To exculpate is to free from blame or guilt; vindicate or exonerate
https://www.thefreedictionary.com/exculpate
cccccccccccccccc
To rehabilitate:1. To restore to good health or useful life, as through therapy and education: rehabilitate a patient; rehabilitate a prison inmate.
2. To restore to good condition: rehabilitate a storefront; rehabilitate the economy.
3. To cause to be regarded again in a positive way; reestablish esteem for: rehabilitate a reputation; rehabilitate a forgotten poet.
4. To restore the former rank, privileges, or rights of: Under the new regime, party members who had been sent to prison were rehabilitated.
https://www.thefreedictionary.com/rehabilitate
Anna Kostorna (asker) Dec 21, 2021:
exonerative grounds?

Proposed translations

+1
15 mins
Selected

exculpatory grounds

prosecutor to proceed with a prosecution automatically leads to the termination of the criminal case based on exculpatory grounds
https://www.ey.com/en_uz/tax-alerts/2020/09/ey-la-uz-improve...

Thanks to the well-prepared defence, the criminal case was terminated on exculpatory grounds.
https://bclplaw.ru/en/partners/angela-glamazdina/

Notwithstanding the foregoing, on facts, the exculpatory grounds in favor of the
defendant, set forth in article 12, section X of the state criminal code,2 are present and have been established since her behavior was compelled, in part, by the conditions prior to the illicit act, resulting from her social background and, in another part, from the specific circumstances in which the events presented themselves, as well as the specific personal circumstances of the defendant, for the following reasons:
https://www.globalhealthrights.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/0...

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 21 mins (2021-12-21 16:45:19 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

ccccccccc
It is also inevitable during a two-stage process that judgments will be formed
about the accused’s person during the initial stage (with respect to, say, evidence of intent and guilt, or the existence of exculpatory grounds).
https://repository.wodc.nl/bitstream/handle/20.500.12832/202...

Peer comment(s):

agree Denis Fesik : All things considered, I believe I should side with you on this one; I like 'exonerative' too
57 mins
Thank you, Denis. Exonerative is in the same family as exculpatory. Exonerative is not commonly used in jurisprudence and is more absolute. Exculpatory tends or serves to clear from alleged fault or guilt.
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "thank you!"
10 mins

rehabilitative grounds



--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 15 мин (2021-12-21 16:39:02 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Например:

As the statute’s name implies, a conviction is set aside
under the DCYRA on rehabilitative grounds having nothing
to do with the merits of the underlying criminal judgment.
...
We agree, and hold that because Phan’s 2002 conviction
was set aside on rehabilitative grounds, USCIS properly considered
it when passing on Phan’s application for naturalization.
https://www.google.ru/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd...
Something went wrong...
26 mins

grounds for rehabilitation

////
Peer comment(s):

neutral Oleg Lozinskiy : А чем (с юридической точки зрения) "rehabilitative grounds" отличаются от "grounds for rehabilitation"???
3 hrs
звучит лучше, на мой взгляд, но это дело вкуса.
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search