Jan 15, 2010 17:23
14 yrs ago
2 viewers *
English term

cd (capitalised or not?)

Non-PRO English Marketing Marketing website promoting classical music
Simple question, and I think I know the answer already, but I'd just like to check.

I've received a text for final proofreading which says "Take a look inside this book and listen to the music on the cd if you want to know how to make your day relaxing with classical music."

Now, I would normally write "CD" myself, but is it actually incorrect to write "cd"? I don't want to change it if it isn't actually wrong, but it's not at all easy to check it out.

So, votes please. Thanks.
Responses
4 +15 CD

Discussion

Sheila Wilson (asker) Jan 16, 2010:
Thanks everyone I know it seems a stupid question, and I certainly wouldn't have queried it in a translation, but I'm performing a QA role here and the rules are a bit different. Thanks for your patience.
urbom Jan 15, 2010:
Google search tips "By attaching a + immediately before a word (remember, don't add a space after the +), you are telling Google to match that word precisely as you typed it."

In the first 10 pages of results returned by Google after searching for +CD, I don't see a single instance of a lower-case spelling in running text (i.e. not in a page title, URL, keywords etc.) that refers to a compact disc. A few of the hits refer to certificates of deposit or computer commands, so let's say that 0 out of 95 occurrences in that sample are in lower case and refer to compact discs.

Personally, I'd find that sort of ratio, combined with a glance in a reputable dictionary and perhaps another style guide or two for good measure, quite persuasive.
Sheila Wilson (asker) Jan 15, 2010:
Thanks urbom I understand your reasons for suggesting a dictionary lookup, but I just wanted to double-check as this text was really well written and I haven't lived in my native country (the UK) for over 15 years now. Your Google search link still doesn't help me tie it down to "cd" rather than "CD", does it?
urbom Jan 15, 2010:
Why use a dictionary? My reason for recommending the use of a (reliable!) dictionary as a reference here is that one can then rely on it as an authority if one is asked to justify the changes made during editing. This is particularly relevant for clients who may overestimate their knowledge of the language in question.
Sheila Wilson (asker) Jan 15, 2010:
Thanks to all @ urbom & writeaway: I realise it can be found in dictionaries as CD, but language (esp. English) is not always reflected adequately in dictionaries. @ writeaway - I tried searching the web, but I don't know how to get searches to respect case (any hints gratefully accepted). @ jccantrell - that sums up my problem perfectly. @ all - thanks for the confirmation that "cd" is not acceptable. This was copy (not translation) from a Polish source and the English was top quality (apart from this), obviously by native or equiv. so I needed to be sure. I'll award points later in accordance with KudoZ rules.

Responses

+15
3 mins
Selected

CD

since it's an abbreviation = Compact Disc

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 4 mins (2010-01-15 17:27:44 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compact_Disc
Peer comment(s):

agree Susana Valdez
0 min
Thanks!
agree Mark Nathan
0 min
Thanks!
agree Jack Doughty : I have never actually seen this abbreviation in lower case.
1 min
Thanks!
agree MPGS : :)
2 mins
Thanks!
agree Nibus : absolutely, CD
3 mins
Thanks!
agree Rolf Keiser
4 mins
Thanks!
agree Sven Petersson : cd = candela
6 mins
Thanks!
agree Yasutomo Kanazawa
7 mins
Thanks!
agree English2Korean
10 mins
Thanks, English2Korean!
agree jccantrell : While this is correct, I am finding that caps appear to be considered more and more optional by people of my kids' generation. Maybe has to do with cell phone texting, but I always feel like I am reading e.e. cummings.
48 mins
Thanks!
agree writeaway : easily checkable on www and in dicos
2 hrs
Thanks!
agree Stanislaw Czech, MCIL CL
3 hrs
Thanks!
agree Stephanie Ezrol
4 hrs
Thanks!
agree inmb : even in Polish, it's CD; I assume it was carelessly written
4 hrs
Thanks!
agree Peter Skipp : There is, however, a very clear (err-r... "past-emerged," to coin a phrase) trend to lowercasing formerly capitalised abbreviations, as also noted by jjcantrell. I'd check with the client for their preference...
16 hrs
Thanks!
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Guess what, Andrey - you got the points! Thanks for your patience for what must have seemed a silly question"

Reference comments

32 mins
Reference:

Use a dictionary

Why not use a reputable dictionary as a reference? The Compact Oxford English Dictionary of Current English is searchable online free of charge: http://www.askoxford.com/dictionaries/?view=uk

(... and it gives only the fully capitalised spelling, no lower-case variant.)
Peer comments on this reference comment:

agree Rob Grayson : Good grief...
1 hr
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search