May 12, 2006 18:18
18 yrs ago
German term

kommunalistisch verfaßt

German to English Social Sciences History
"Die ostfriesische Gemeinde entsprach insgesamt der von Peter Blickle beschriebenen *kommunalistisch verfaßten* Gemeinde, die über eine Grundausstattung an Satzungs-, Gerichts- und Strafkompetenz verfügte."

I translated this as communally-minded, but the customer isn't happy with this formulation, in particular he feels that the term communalism or a derivative of it is an essential term, which needs to be included as such in the sentence.
Any thoughts and suggestions appreciated.

Discussion

Jeremy Amos (asker) May 12, 2006:
Hi Henry, no, there's no comment on the "verfaßt" question, but the adjectival form of communalism is communalistic, not communal.
Also Kim, I considered communalistically, but googling it, it's sufficiently rare to constitute a neologism, and I prefer to avoid neologisms in general and here especially.
Henry Schroeder May 12, 2006:
Did your customer say anything about what was meant by "verfaßt" in this context or could you shed some light on its meaning here? I also don't understand how you tranlation with "communal" is not a derivative of "communalism". It's the adjective.

Proposed translations

9 hrs
Selected

premised on communalistic values

Overall the ... community conformed to Peter Blickle's model of a community that is premised on communalistic values and has the basic...

I believe "verfaßt" is sufficiently vague to be interpreted widely, though I am not sure if "values" may be going to far in interpretation. Perhaps "communalistic social organization" would be an alternative.

Essentially if the community is structured along communalistic lines, their values are in turn likely to be similar. Nevertheless, you will know whether this is possible from your context.

I would not use "communalistically", which I think is very uncommon and sounds clumsy. The original construction with the adverb before the past participle acting as an adjective is more common in German than it is in English, as I'm sure you know. If nothing else, I would just write "a communalist society", since, as I have said, "verfaßt" seems to be more of embellishment.

"Premised on", I think, is nice and fairly academic. Good to impress your customer. "based on", "structured on the basis of" are all of course other possibilities.

Here is the source text I was reading. Perhaps it might give you other suggestions:

Communalism as a Value, the Value of Communalism

Gary Urton (1992) raises the question of whether or not the values and practices informing the cosmology of people in his research site of Pacariqtambo, and by extension, in other communities of the Andes, also represent organizing principles of social organization, and if so, to what degree. He proposes that communalism and differentiation are central values and organizing principles of social life, and provides a rich and provocative discussion of how these values get played out in phayna (community work party) activity. As he puts it, "it is the dialectical relationship between communalism and differentiation which . . . motivates work by everyone in the community on certain tasks, but which at the same time insists that such tasks should be performed by people working in their different ayllu groupings" (Urton 1992:231). Accordingly, he concludes that "These two values are in constant dialectical relationship with each other in the life of the village."

The question raised by Urton is of broad interest, given that all too often in the Andean literature communalism as intent (norm, value, worldview) is confused or conflated with communalism as institution (ayllu, comunidad campesina) or communalism as action (people working together in ayni, etc.). The first presupposes that cooperation is an ethic, a preferred way of doing things. The second includes rule-making and rule-enforcing mechanisms that go beyond moral incentives to ensure cooperation. The third is measurable cooperative behavior, however it arises and is maintained.

In a broad sense, Urton is most certainly right that in the southern Andes of Peru "relations among individuals and groups ***are premised on both communalistic and individualistic values*** and motivations, and that the practices through which socioeconomic and political relations are conducted daily and reproduced over time are products of the dialectic . . . between communalism and differentiation" (Urton 1992:233). The challenge is to make sense of what this might mean in terms of individual thought processes, and how they become aggregated among the whole.

http://66.249.93.104/search?q=cache:LSpVnH5ntX0J:www.euskaln...
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thanks to all of you for your helpful suggestions. I discussed it with the customer and we simply rewrote it."
13 mins

with a communalist structure

My "New Oxford Dictionary of English" has this definition:
communalism
noun [MASS NOUN]
1 a principle of political organization based on federated communes.
the principle or practice of living together and sharing possessions and responsibilities.
2 allegiance to one's own ethnic group rather than to the wider society.

See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communalist
Peer comment(s):

neutral Olga Cartlidge : No, I don t. With a strong sense of identity as a community is just a guess.
5 hrs
The sentence quoted speaks of local laws and court structures rather than ethnic awareness. Or do you have more background information about Blickle?//Communalism is a whole political/social philosophy - see my URL and Kim's comments.
Something went wrong...
17 mins

communistically organised

In the nineteenth century, other Protestant groups founded communities in the United States. One of the earliest and most successful was headed by “Father” George Rapp, a German religious leader. After migrating to Pennsylvania in 1804, he and his group of over 1700 followers founded a communistically organized colony in Beaver County, north of Pittsburgh.

http://www.d.umn.edu/~aroos/modernutopias.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communalism


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 20 mins (2006-05-12 18:38:45 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Students will study two communities for comparison: (1) a purely secular community (Owen’s experiment in New Harmony, Ohio); and (2) a strictly religious one (Noyes’ community in Oneida, New York). Though both communities were communistically organized, i.e., both shared property and wealth, they were quite different in goals, methods and achievements. Students should become aware of the diversity possible within such communal living experiences. Another goal that I have is for students to appreciate the religious, economic and social conditions present in nineteenth-century America that led to the formation of literally hundreds of small communities such as the ones outlined in this unit. I expect that students will be able to develop some sort of criteria for judging “successes” and “failures” of such social experiments.
http://www.yale.edu/ynhti/curriculum/units/1989/1/89.01.04.x...
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search