Oct 18, 2013 21:41
10 yrs ago
English term

was inaugureted or inaugurated

Non-PRO English Other Other
The restoration of the main hall and chumon gate (inner gate) of xxx Temple: The main hall was inaugurated in FY 2007 and the chumon gate in FY 2008 at the historic site of the Enichiji Temple

I changed the above into the following;
The main hall of xxx Temple Site restored in FY 2007 and
the chumon gate (inner gate) in FY 2008

The main hall of xxx Temple Site restored and inaugurated in FY 2007 and the chumon gate (inner gate) in FY 2008

I hope to have your comments.

Thank you.

Discussion

Mitsuko Yoshida Oct 21, 2013:
BD, Thank you very much. Your comment was very helpful.
B D Finch Oct 20, 2013:
@Asker There are a number of ways that a native speaker of English might reduce this caption to a manageable length by omitting definite articles and "was" (Sue-my's comment about possible confusion with "is" is wrong and seems confused). However, providing you with an entire caption seems to go beyond the scope of KudoZ.
Mitsuko Yoshida Oct 19, 2013:
Tina, Thank you very much for your comment. In general, an inauguration ceremony is ineviably conducted when a temple is completed or restored. So I think it is not necessary to say inaugurated. Also the original sentence is too long for the space.
Tina Vonhof (X) Oct 19, 2013:
Why not keep the original sentence? Your first suggestion fails to mention 'inauguration' and your second suggestion assumes that the restoration and inauguration took place in the same year, which may or not be true. I don't see anything wrong with the original sentence - it seems perfectly clear.
Mitsuko Yoshida Oct 19, 2013:
David, I forgot to say that I understand and agree with the explanation by Tony.
Mitsuko Yoshida Oct 19, 2013:
(continuation) And the native speaker agreed with Tony. But "The" of The main hall should be cut. Is that so? I learnt that "which is (was)" can be omitted. But be careful when omitting WAS so as not to be confused with IS.
Mitsuko Yoshida Oct 19, 2013:
Thank you David. Two refurbishment works were finished in 2007 and 2008, respectively. Another native speaker said only restored will do.
I think so. (to be condinued.)
David Moore (X) Oct 19, 2013:
yoshimi, I'm a bit uneasy about these answers, as I understand you to have altered 'inaugurated' to 'restored'. There is a clear difference between the two, as 'restoration' is the work of refurbishment, while 'inauguration' is normally a ceremonious reopening to public viewing, use etc. of something which has been restored. You must therefore be absolutely clear as to which is meant.

In either case, it must be expressed with the passive voice and the 'was' is thus essential, except as Tony M describes.
yoshimi (asker) Oct 18, 2013:
Addition: This is a caption to a photo.

Responses

1 hr
English term (edited): was inaugurated or inaugurated
Selected

inaugurated

Actually, it depends how it is being used.

If your sentence is intended to be read as "(Here is) the X, (which was) restored in Y and inaugurated in Z", then it is perfectly acceptable to leave out the 'was' in the sort of shorthand language one uses in titles, legends, etc.
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thank you very much. I really appreciate your taking time to answer my question. "
+4
29 mins

was inaugurated

You have to use the passive form in this case.
If you use the active form the meaning changes completely.
ex.The PM inaugurated the Main Hall in....
The main hall was inaugurated in...by the PM
The same applies to restore
Peer comment(s):

agree Jack Doughty
30 mins
thank you
agree Edith Kelly
6 hrs
Thanks
agree writeaway : the word 'was' is missing and is necessary. was restored and inaugurated.
10 hrs
thank you
agree Jenni Lukac (X)
10 hrs
thank you
agree Steffen Walter
11 hrs
thank you
disagree B D Finch : As this is a caption, not intended to be flowing text, and as the dates are given and are clearly in the past, it is perfectly OK to omit "was". E.g. Main hall - inaugurated FY 2007. Cursive style is acceptable for captions.
1 day 11 hrs
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search